<\body> Stories in America: Who Makes the News?

Wednesday, February 15, 2006

Who Makes the News?

Look at any news 'personality' site and what stands out? White men. The majority of TV and radio show hosts are men. The majority of the people who make the final decisions about what gets covered and what doesn't are men.

A new study by the World Association for Christian Communication, a non-governmental organization that promotes communication for social change, found that while women make up 52 percent of the world's population, they make up only 21 percent of news subjects. The findings are based on news items appearing on a single day (Feb. 16, 2005). Almost 13,000 news items were surveyed on that day in 76 countries:

Within the 21 percent space they get as subjects, they do not always appear for the best reasons. ''They are more likely to be found in what is referred to as the soft end of the news spectrum, celebrity stories, social and legal issues,'' said the WACC's Anna Turley. ''They are much less present in the politics and economics stories which of course make up the bulk of the news agenda.''

Within media ''what we are seeing is that print media lags far behind radio and television,'' Turley said. Only 29 percent of the women behind the news in print are women, relative to the average of 37 percent.

In television news reporting women outnumber men. The study says in the reports scrutinised from the 76 countries, 58 percent were by women.

But that is not necessarily pleasing WACC. ''What we see is that the number of women below the age of 35 in television is far greater,'' Turley said. ''Interestingly, past the age of 35 we see far more men reporting the news than women. That of course suggests that appearance and age are a criteria for women journalists and not for men.''

The Global Media Monitoring Project as it is called was first conducted in 1995 and then again in 2000 and 2005. Besides finding little improvement in representation of women as news subjects, the survey showed also that the pattern can be similar in countries as dissimilar as Britain and Zimbabwe.

Some other findings:

Women are least represented in radio where they are only 17 percent of the subjects compared to 22 percent in television and 21 percent in newspapers.

As many as 86 percent of people featured as spokespersons were men.

Women are more than twice as likely to be portrayed as victims than men.

Female reporters are more likely to cover the 'soft' news.

Only 10 percent of the stories have women as a central focus.

Only 3 percent of stories challenge stereotypes, compared to 6 percent that reinforce them.
As many as 96 percent of stories do not highlight gender equality or inequality.

The imbalance might just be worse than this report suggests. ''I think the survey was slightly urban-based because that is where women are working in the news media,'' Arul Aram from The Hindu newspaper in India, who was associated with the study told IPS. ''In rural areas women are yet to come up.''


At 2/15/2006 12:27 PM, Anonymous timmy said...

There's also a tremendous gender gap in the blogosphere. Readers and writers of blogs are predominantly male, by a substantial margin.

What makes this disparity different than some of the venues you listed is that the blogosphere is completely democratic. There's no vetting, no arbitrary social constructs, no handicapping. The blog gender gap transcends political point of view as well.

Any ideas on this?


Post a Comment

<< Home